Friday, 25 January 2013

90% dental college proposals rejected

TNN Jan 15, 2013, 03.50AM IST

LUCKNOW: Strict rules have resulted in rejection of 90% proposals to open new dental colleges in the past year. "As many as 110 colleges were not given recognition to run a dental college because of stringent norms. Only 10 were considered and given approval in the year 2012,'' said Dr Dibyendu Mazumdar, president, Dental Council of India (DCI). Dr Mazumdar was in the city on Monday to attend college day function at Babu Banarsi Das Institute of Dental Sciences.

He said the DCI recognised only those dental institutes with other medical departments such as ENT, eye, orthopedic and others. "This is to ensure efficient clinical material-patient inflow-in the college,'' said Dr Mazumdar. At times, patients who visit eye or ENT or any other department are referred to the dentist.

DCI president also pointed out that clinical practice in the government colleges was far better than in private ones.

"A dental science student gets better exposure in government college due to enhanced techniques compared to a private college. In fact, there is no match between the two,'' said Dr Mazumdar.

Stressing quality of dental education, he said, "State governments play a major role in deciding the quality of dentistry. For opening a new college, it is the state government that gives a no-objection certificate. Only after this, it is sent to the Central government. The DCI only checks whether the norms are being followed or not.''

He also said the rate of employment of dentists is comparatively very low in ratio to the number of students who pass out every year. According to figures, there are approximately 2,100 students eligible for dentistry every year from UP. But, job posts sanctioned for them are less than 10%. The expert said primary health centres (PHCs) and community health centres (CHCs) do not have post for dentists. Dr Mazumdar said the state government should create more jobs for such students under schemes like NHRM.

On the occasion, Media in charge of BBDIDS Vivek Govila said many students and teachers were felicitated for outstanding contributions to the field of dental sciences.

Source: http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2013-01-15/lucknow/36352567_1_dental-college-dental-sciences-dental-institutes

Action against erring members: DCI chief

By Express News Service - BANGALORE  | 24th January 2013 08:04 AM

Dr Dibyendu Mazumdar, President, Dental Council of India (DCI), told Express that the council would take appropriate action against erring members. The CBI conducted raids on the residences of RGUHS Senate and DCI members         Dr Jayakar Shetty in Bangalore and Bharat Shetty in Mangalore on Wednesday.

The raids were conducted after their names propped up during the investigation of a bribery case in Chennai.

Sources said six private dental colleges were searched after a DCI member was allegedly caught taking bribe for setting up of new dental colleges.

Dr Sriprakash , VC of RGUHS, said he was not aware of the developments of CBI investigation.

Source: http://newindianexpress.com/cities/bangalore/article1433352.ece

Indian Dental Association wants to play proactive role in academic matters

By Sudha Nambudiri, TNN | Jan 25, 2013, 05.22 AM IST

KOCHI: The Indian Dental Association (IDA) has suggested that they would like to play a proactive role in the academic matters of the Dental Council of India following the arrest of DCI members Dr Murukesan and Dr Gunaseelan by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) on charges of corruption.

In a letter to the Union health minister Ghulam Nabi Azad, the IDA national vice-president, Dr M Raveendranath said that the DCI had become corrupt with the private stakeholders coming into the dental education scenario.

"There are unethical interests in sanctioning new dental colleges and PG and UG seats. Most of the private colleges are interested only in profit and that too at the cost of social responsibility. They go to any extent and collude with anybody to get their due share. But they are relegating the fact that dentists without proper education and training are a social threat and affect public health. Most of the dental colleges are without the stipulated infrastructure and with abysmally low patient turnout. Staff patterns are maintained only on register of inspection days and on other days it is compensated with underpaid fresh graduates. At the same time, the well run government dental colleges are struggling to get what they deserve, to run the institution well," Dr Ravindranath told TOI.

Recently, the application for new government dental colleges at Thrissur and Alappuzha were rejected by DCI. Moulana Azad Dental College with state of the art facilities and 1,500 patients a day at Delhi is still admitting only 40 students a year and that is the ideal strength to give maximum attention and clinical training to students."We have suggested that social auditing is the only solution for this menace to break the unholy alliance between stakeholders," he said.

"IDA is the one and only registered organization working among dentists and can take up wide range of activities related to dentistry," said Dr Ravindranath.

Source: http://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/kochi/Indian-Dental-Association-wants-to-play-proactive-role-in-academic-matters/articleshow/18176042.cms

Beed dental college students meet CM, seek transfer

Express news service : Thu Jan 17 2013, 01:36 hrs

Students claimed college management started harassing them after they reported lack of facilities to an NGO.

Students of Aditya Dental College (ADC), Beed, and members of NGO Forum for Fairness in Education, which is championing their cause, met CM Prithviraj Chavan Tuesday evening.

The students claimed harassment and sought stringent action against the ADC management and urged CM to transfer them to another college.

Around 70 first-year BDS students alleged the college had been harassing them ever since they complained against poor infrastructure and lack of basic facilities.

"We submitted a list of grievances to CM and the health and medical education minister. CM promised stringent action," a student said.

Another said, "We feel cheated. Now, it is the responsibility of the state government to transfer us to another college or else we will lose an academic year. The college management has been harassing us since the time we openly complained about it to NGO Forum for Fairness in Education. The college does not have basic facilities such as lights, fans in classrooms, laboratory and sufficient number of cadavers."

Most students have left the college and are seeking a transfer to another.

ADC administrator Aditi Sarda, however, denied the charges. She claimed the college had good infrastructure and provided all facilities to students.

A 2012 CAG report claimed a large number of dental colleges in the country, including ADC, were allowed despite negative reports against managements.

An audit of 82 dental colleges between 2006 and 2011 revealed 13 (15.85 per cent) of the colleges were granted permission by the health ministry despite negative recommendations by Dental Council of India.

While many institutes had shortage of faculty, others could not meet norms. Maharashtra Institute of Dental Sciences in Latur, Sinhgad Dental College in Pune and Yogita Dental College in Ratnagiri were also on the 'negative' list.

Source:  http://www.indianexpress.com/news/beed-dental-college-students-meet-cm-seek-transfer/1060450/1

CBI raids dental council members in B’lore, M’lore

Bangalore:Jan 24, 2013 DH News Service

The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI), continued its investigation into an alleged bribery case related to grant of approval to colleges for running various courses by members of Dental Council of India (DCI) and searched several places, including Bangalore and Mangalore.

CBI sources told Deccan Herald over phone that the agency expanded its probe searching premises of three members of the council's executive committee and six private dental colleges, in different places of the country.

They revealed that premises of executive committee members, Dr S M Jayakar in Bangalore, Y Bharat Shetty in Mangalore and Sateesh Kumar Reddy in Hyderabad were searched.

Another source said both Jayakar and Bharath Shetty, were in Delhi for an executive committee meeting when the searches were carried out.

Insiders give clue

“The searches were carried out based on the information provided by some insiders,” a source said, without revealing the names of whistle-blowers.

Having received leads that some private colleges were given permissions to run courses despite several inadequacies in the infrastructure among other things, the agency also raided about six private dental colleges.

The searches happened in Bangalore, Mangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad, Namakkal and Jabalpur, sources said.

The CBI, on January 21, had arrested a Dental Council of India member (of a private dental college and hospital at Melmaruvathur, in Tamil Nadu) in an on-going
investigation of an alleged bribery case relating to grant of approval by Dental Council of India for starting.Post-Graduate Dental Course in 2012.

And earlier, (during second week of January, 2013) the agency had arrested a Member of Dental Council of India for accepting a bribe of Rs 25 lakh and three private persons/officials of a private dental college and hospital at Melmaruvathur for offering the bribe.

Trust involved

During initial investigation of this case, it was found that bribe amounts were allegedly accounted through a Trust in Chennai functioning at the dental clinic owned and run by the arrested Member of DCI. Both the arrested members were the Trustees of the said Trust.

Searches were conducted at the residential premises of accused at Chennai and the trust office at Chennai.

A sum of Rs 75 lakh was also recovered from a private person who was allegedly associated with the arrested Dental Council of India member in the matter of granting approval to various dental colleges.


Source: http://www.deccanherald.com/content/307302/cbi-raids-dental-council-members.html

Chennai: CBI raids 4 dental colleges, officials

TNN Jan 24, 2013, 06.23AM IST

CHENNAI: The CBI on Wednesday searched 10 properties of four dental colleges and their administrators in connection with bribes reportedly paid to members of the Dental Council of India for permission for postgraduate courses. Sleuths carried out simultaneous raids around noon and continued the searches till late in the evening.

The CBI searched the premises of the Thai Moogambigai Dental College at Mogappair and the residence of the college's administrator in T Nagar; the Asan Memorial Dental College and Hospital at Chengalpet and the residence of a college official in Nungambakkam; and the campuses of the JKK Nataraja Dental College in Nammakkal and the Hitkerini Dental College in Jabalpur, Madhya Pradesh. Corruption, lack of transparency plague DCI

'Body Given Powers & Responsibilities Without Ensuring Checks & Balances'

The Dental Council of India (DCI), a statutory body that regulates dental education , is plagued with corruption and lack of transparency.

On Wednesday, CBI officials raided three of the 26 dental colleges in Tamil Nadu for allegedly bribing DCI members to get approval to introduce courses and increase the number of seats. Raids are also being conducted in offices and residences of some DCI members across the country. Almost simultaneously , DCI's executive committee met in New Delhi. "The Tamil Nadu government has withdrawn the name of Dr R Gunaseelan as the state nominee . We have requested Annamalai University to consider withdrawing its nominee Dr Murukesan," said DCI secretary S K Ojha. The two dentists were arrested by the CBI on corruption charges. The council has not considered cancelling their registration yet, he said.

Three years ago, the Medical Council of India, came under flak for corruption and its president Ketan Desai was arrested for granting permission to a private medical college without adequate infrastructure . Senior dentists and professors say corruption in dental education is no different.

Many colleges lack basic facilities such as buildings, labs and teaching faculty. The teaching standards in most colleges are poor as the faculty is inexperienced . "We need to cut down the number of medical colleges ," said Salem-based dentist George Paul, who has been campaigning for transparency in the dental education sector.

According to the World Health Organization, an ideal dentist to patient ratio is 1:7,500. With 295 dental colleges, India is churning out nearly 30,000 dentists every year. More than 90% of the colleges are private.

The DCI has said there are too many doctors for too few patients . The dentist to patient ratio in Maharashtra is 1:5,000. In TN it is 1:4,500 and in Kerala it is 1:3,300. Tamil Nadu has one government dental college, which offers 100 BDS seats, 19 self-financing colleges affiliated to the state medical university, and six colleges run by deemed universities. A former DCI member from Chennai said the influence private colleges have on the DCI is high. "Neither the election nor the nominations to DCI posts are transparent. Only influential dentists or those with money get elected. They show their gratitude by getting sanctions for undeserving colleges ," he said.

The bottom line for corruption in both MCI and DCI, doctors say, are the same. "We have given powers and responsibilities without ensuring checks and balances," said senior orthopaediacian George Thomas, former editor of Indian Journal of Medical Ethics.

Action against graft: the story so far

Jan 8: CBI officials arrest DCI member S Murugesan for allegedly demanding Rs 1 crore as bribe from a private dental college
Jan 14: CBI sleuths raid the Adyar residence of DCI member R Gunaseelan, who is also the president of state dental council
Jan 15: The CBI sends lookout circular to airports after they receive information that Gunaseelan had fled the country
Jan 18: R Gunaseelan is arrested after prolonged interrogation for his involvement in the graft case
Jan 19: The government withdraws the membership of Gunaseelan and Murukesan from the state dental council and the MCI

Source:  http://articles.timesofindia.indiatimes.com/2013-01-24/chennai/36526241_1_dci-members-dental-colleges-dental-education

Mangalore: DCI bribery case - CBI raids dentist's residence, clinic

Daijiworld Media Network – Mangalore (VM)
With DHNS Inputs

Mangalore, Jan 24: CBI officials from Chennai on Wednesday January 23 raided the residence of dentist Dr Bharath Shetty. His clinic near Attavar was also raided.

The officials reportedly examined all his documents. During their visit, the dentist was absent and family members said that he has been to Delhi on work.

Sources said that the CBI officials have called the dentist to Chennai. Dr Bharath Shetty is also an executive member of the Dental Council of India.

The raids were conducted as part of the CBI investigations into the an alleged bribery case related to grant of approval to colleges for running various courses by members of Dental Council of India (DCI). The CBI searched several places including Bangalore and Hyderabad and six private colleges across the country.

“The searches were carried out based on the information provided by some insiders,” a source said, without revealing the names of whistle-blowers.

Having received leads that some private colleges were given permissions to run courses despite several inadequacies in the infrastructure among other things, the agency also raided about six private dental colleges.

The searches happened in Bangalore, Mangalore, Chennai, Hyderabad, Namakkal and Jabalpur, sources said.

The CBI, on January 21, had arrested a Dental Council of India member (of a private dental college and hospital at Melmaruvathur, in Tamil Nadu) in an on-going investigation of an alleged bribery case relating to grant of approval by Dental Council of India for starting Post-Graduate Dental Course in 2012.

Earlier, (during second week of January, 2013) the agency had arrested a Member of Dental Council of India for accepting a bribe of Rs 25 lakh and three private persons/officials of a private dental college and hospital at Melmaruvathur for offering the bribe.

During initial investigation of this case, it was found that bribe amounts were allegedly accounted through a Trust in Chennai functioning at the dental clinic owned and run by the arrested Member of DCI. Both the arrested members were the Trustees of the said Trust.

Searches were conducted at the residential premises of accused at Chennai and the trust office at Chennai.

A sum of Rs 75 lakh was also recovered from a private person who was allegedly associated with the arrested Dental Council of India member in the matter of granting approval to various dental colleges.


Source: http://www.daijiworld.com/news/news_disp.asp?n_id=161789